Push vs Pull Motivation: The Complete Tony Robbins Framework for Lasting Behavioral Change

TL;DR

• There are two types of motivation: push (willpower-based) and pull (desire-driven)
• Push motivation has limits and fails when you're exhausted; pull motivation creates lasting change
• Your behavior is determined by your mental and emotional state, not just your intentions
• Most people fail because they try to change behavior without getting into the right state first
• A "threshold state" can trigger instant, massive behavioral change
• Focus equals feeling - whatever you focus on determines your emotional state
• You can manage your state through physiology (movement, breathing) and focus

What is Pull Motivation? Pull motivation occurs when there's something you want so badly that you feel pulled towards it, creating lasting behavioral change that willpower alone cannot achieve. — Tony Robbins

The Fatal Flaw of Push Motivation: Why Willpower Always Fails

Most of us operate under a fundamental misunderstanding about motivation. We believe that if we just push ourselves hard enough, discipline ourselves strictly enough, we can force the changes we want to see. This approach - what Tony Robbins calls "push motivation" - is the reason why 95% of people fail to achieve their goals.

"There's two types of motivation in life. There's push motivation where you're trying to make yourself do something," Robbins explains. "But there's a limit. There's a limit to willpower, no matter how much you have. And when you're most exhausted and tired, you notice your willpower may not feel as strong."

This limitation isn't a character flaw - it's neurological. Willpower operates like a muscle that gets fatigued with use. When you're stressed, tired, or emotionally drained, your prefrontal cortex (the brain region responsible for self-control) literally has less capacity to override impulses and maintain discipline.

Consider the typical scenario: You decide to start a diet on Monday. You use tremendous willpower to avoid the donuts in the break room, skip your usual afternoon snack, and prepare a healthy dinner. By Wednesday, your willpower reserves are depleted from constant decision-making and resistance. By Friday, you're back to your old eating habits, feeling guilty and defeated.

This isn't failure - it's predictable biology. Push motivation works temporarily but cannot create sustainable change because it fights against your natural impulses rather than aligning with them. It creates internal resistance and requires constant energy expenditure to maintain.

The most dangerous aspect of push motivation is that it often makes you feel like you're making progress when you're actually setting yourself up for failure. You mistake the effort for effectiveness, the struggle for success. But lasting change doesn't come from struggle - it comes from alignment.

>

Key Insight:

Willpower is a finite resource that depletes with use, making push motivation unsustainable for long-term behavioral change.

The Power of Pull Motivation: Creating Irresistible Desire

Pull motivation operates on an entirely different principle. Instead of forcing yourself to do something, you create such a compelling vision of what you want that you feel naturally drawn toward it. "Pull is there's something you want so badly, you feel pulled towards it," Robbins states. "And pull has this lasting effect that you can never get with push."

The key to creating pull motivation lies in getting extremely specific about your desired outcomes. Vague goals create weak pull. "I want to make more money" generates minimal motivational force because your brain has no clear target to focus on. As Robbins points out: "Fine, here's a dollar, get out of here. Unconsciously, you've already achieved the goal."

Instead, pull motivation requires what Robbins calls results that are "really clear" and "compelling." For example:

• Instead of "lose weight," envision "fit into my wedding dress from 20 years ago and feel confident in photos"

Instead of "make more money," specify "earn $150,000 annually so I can provide private school education for my children"

Instead of "get healthy," define "have the energy to play with my grandchildren without getting winded"

The specificity serves a neurological purpose. Your brain's reticular activating system (RAS) - the filter that determines what you notice in your environment - needs precise instructions to function effectively. When you have a clear, compelling target, your RAS begins highlighting opportunities, resources, and pathways that were previously invisible to you.

Pull motivation also engages your emotional brain in a positive way. Instead of fighting against resistance, you're moving toward something you genuinely want. This creates what psychologists call "approach motivation" - a state where your energy naturally flows toward your goal rather than being depleted by internal conflict.

State Management: The Hidden Key to Behavioral Change

Here's where most personal development advice fails: it focuses on what to do without addressing the state you need to be in to actually do it. "What's gonna actually determine your behavior?" Robbins asks. "It's gonna be the state you're in."

Your mental and emotional state is the lens through which you perceive opportunities, make decisions, and take action. "If you're in a pissed off state, are you going to behave the same way as if you're feeling playful?" The answer is obviously no, yet most people completely ignore this fundamental principle when trying to create change.

Robbins illustrates this with a common scenario: "Someone say, I know, I know. I know, I'm... I need to lose weight, I need to get an exercise program, I need a diet, I'm tired of wearing pants. Is it gonna happen? Not in a million years, why? You know why, because they're not in the right state."

The person has all the cognitive knowledge they need. They understand calories in versus calories out, the importance of exercise, the health risks of being overweight. But knowledge without the right state is powerless. They're in a state of resignation, frustration, or defeat - states that generate behaviors like procrastination, self-sabotage, and excuse-making.

Contrast this with what Robbins calls a "threshold state" - a moment when you've reached your absolute limit: "Have you ever been, how many have been in something where you didn't do it, didn't do it, didn't do it, and got mad at yourself, mad at yourself, till one day it's like, not another day, not another hour, I'm changing this now, and you took massive action."

In a threshold state, behavior changes instantly and dramatically. The same person who couldn't stick to a diet for three days suddenly declares a 10-day water fast. The same person who tolerated a toxic relationship for years suddenly ends it permanently. The threshold state bypasses all the mental negotiations and excuses that normally sabotage change efforts.

The Race Car Lesson: Focus Determines Everything

Robbins shares a powerful metaphor from his experience at racing school that illustrates how focus shapes both state and behavior. When learning to drive at 235 miles per hour, every muscle locks because "it takes more focus than anything, every energy is there, it's pure adrenaline."

The instructor, Bob Bondurant, taught him a critical lesson using a "spin car" - a vehicle that could be sent into an uncontrolled spin at any moment. The secret to regaining control? "Focus on where you want to go, not on what you fear."

This principle extends far beyond racing. "Whatever you focus on, you unconsciously steer towards," Robbins explains. "What do most people focus on? What they want or what they fear?" Unfortunately, most people focus on what they fear - losing what they have or not getting what they want.

This creates a destructive cycle. When you focus on what you don't want (getting fired, staying broke, being alone), you create the emotional state that generates behaviors leading to those exact outcomes. Your brain, following your focus, starts looking for evidence that supports your fears and overlooks opportunities that could lead to what you actually want.

The racing metaphor is particularly powerful because it demonstrates how even life-threatening situations can be navigated successfully with proper focus. "If you've ever heard about a person driving their brand new Porsche down a country road, and there's like one telephone pole every quarter of a mile, and they lose control and hit the pole. How in the hell do they hit the pole? Because when losing control, what do they do? They go, oh, I don't want to hit that. And whatever you focus on, you unconsciously steer towards."

Key Insight:

Your focus equals your feeling, and your feeling determines your behavior. Master your focus, and you master your results.

The Two Primary Tools for State Management

Robbins identifies two primary methods for instantly changing your state, both of which are completely under your control:

1. Radical Change in Physiology

"A radical change in your physiology, the way you move, the way you breathe," is the first tool. Your physiology and psychology are inextricably linked. When you're in a depressed state, notice your posture - shoulders slumped, head down, shallow breathing. When you're confident and energized, your physiology is completely different - upright posture, deeper breathing, animated movement.

The revolutionary insight is that you can use this connection in reverse. Instead of waiting to feel motivated before taking action, you can change your physiology first and create the motivation. "If you're just sitting there doing these things, stressed out, you need to get up and change your state."

This isn't positive thinking - it's applied neuroscience. Different physical postures literally change your hormone production. Power poses increase testosterone and decrease cortisol. Deep breathing activates the parasympathetic nervous system, reducing stress and increasing clarity.

2. Changing Your Focus

The second tool is redirecting your focus. "The other way we can do it instantly is changing our focus. Remind yourself, focus equals feeling. Whatever you focus on, you're gonna feel. Even if it's not true, you're gonna feel it."

This principle explains why two people can experience the identical event and have completely different emotional responses. It's not the event that determines your state - it's what aspect of the event you choose to focus on.

For example, losing a job can be focused on as:

• A catastrophic failure that proves your incompetence
• An opportunity to find something better aligned with your values
• A chance to finally start the business you've been dreaming about
• Evidence that the universe is pushing you toward your true calling

The external facts are identical, but the focus determines whether you feel devastated or excited, paralyzed or motivated.

How to Apply This Framework: 5 Steps to Sustainable Change

1. Get Crystal Clear on Your Compelling Result

Move beyond vague goals to specific, emotionally charged outcomes. Instead of "get in shape," define exactly what being in shape means to you and why it matters. What will you be able to do? How will you feel? What will change in your life?

2. Identify Your Current State Patterns

Become aware of the states you typically experience when facing challenges. Do you get overwhelmed? Frustrated? Resigned? Notice the physiology and focus patterns that create these states.

3. Design Your Success State

Identify the mental and emotional state that would make your desired behaviors natural and easy. What would you need to feel to take consistent action? Confident? Excited? Determined? Playful?

4. Practice State Management Daily

Make changing your state a daily practice. Use physiology (exercise, breathing, posture) and focus (visualization, gratitude, purpose) to condition yourself into empowering states.

5. Embrace the Lag Time

Understand that "when you start doing things right, do you instantly get rewarded? Not usually, there's usually something called lag time." Like Robbins says about dieting: "I've been on a diet for four days. I haven't lost any weight. Well, you've been a pig for 40 years. What do you think?"

Mastery Through Repetition: Building Lasting Habits

The racing school experience taught Robbins another crucial lesson about lasting change: mastery comes through repetition, not understanding. "It's not enough to understand it. I understood I shouldn't look at the wall. You're gonna understand you shouldn't keep asking yourself, what should I do? But it's your habit for a lifetime."

Initial attempts at state management will feel awkward and require conscious effort. But with repetition, new patterns become automatic. "Information without emotion is barely retained. But information with a lot of emotion and repetition is absolutely retained."

The key is to practice during low-stakes situations so the skills are available during high-stakes moments. "After we've done this about a dozen times," Robbins notes, the new responses become automatic. When the "button gets pushed" and you start spinning out of control, you instinctively focus on where you want to go rather than what you fear.

This is why the greatest performers in any field "keep practicing what they're already great at. They're practicing 100 million times more than they're actually taking the shot. But that's how they're best in the world."

Key Insight:

Mastery isn't about avoiding spins - it's about getting so good at recovering from them that setbacks become setups for greater success.

Common Mistakes That Sabotage Success

Based on Robbins' framework, here are the most common mistakes people make when trying to create change:

Relying Solely on Push Motivation: Trying to force change through willpower alone, ignoring the natural limitations of self-control.

Setting Vague Goals: Using general desires like "lose weight" or "make money" instead of specific, compelling outcomes that create real pull.

Ignoring State Management: Trying to change behavior without first getting into the right mental and emotional state.

Focusing on Problems: Concentrating on what you don't want instead of what you do want, unconsciously steering toward negative outcomes.

Expecting Instant Results: Getting discouraged during lag time instead of understanding that momentum takes time to build.

Avoiding Practice: Thinking that understanding is enough, rather than building new neural pathways through repetition.

The Ultimate Truth About Change

Robbins' racing car metaphor reveals the ultimate truth about change: "Everyone, even if you're the best driver in the world, you're going to go into a spin. You know why? Somebody's car is going to break up in front of you. There's going to be an oil spot you can't see. There's going to be some debris. That's life."

The goal isn't to avoid challenges, setbacks, or temporary failures. The goal is to become so skilled at managing your state and focus that you can quickly regain control and continue moving toward your destination.

This perspective transforms how you view obstacles. Instead of seeing them as evidence of your inadequacy or reasons to quit, you recognize them as inevitable parts of the journey that can actually strengthen your skills and resolve.

When you truly understand and apply these principles, you develop what Robbins calls "emotional fitness" - the ability to consistently access empowering states regardless of external circumstances. This is the foundation of all lasting achievement and fulfillment.

The framework is simple but not easy. It requires consistent practice, emotional honesty, and the willingness to take responsibility for your internal state rather than blaming external circumstances. But for those committed to mastery, it offers a proven path to creating any change you desire in your life.

---

This article was created from video content by Tony Robbins. The content has been restructured and optimized for readability while preserving the original insights and voice.